Open media
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2005“1. When Google first unveiled video.google.com, you had to use their patched version of VLC to play videos there, and if you used Google’s patched version of VLC, it would only play items hosted on http://video.google.com. (They have since changed over to a Flash player using FLV, which is not like this).
2. If you want to watch news video on MSNBC.com, you have to be using Internet Explorer or you will get an error message saying that IE is required. It’s not good enough to have Windows Media Player as either a standalone or plugin, and it’s not good enough to use an alternate media player like VLC which is capable of rendering Windows Media. It’s possible that there are technical issues associated with this (probably the site relies on features specific to IE) but not that these technical issues were insurmountable.
3. If you want to browse the iTunes music store over the web, you have to be using iTunes as your web browser. With Internet Explorer or any other browser aside from iTunes, you get an error message saying that you must use iTunes.
What these have in common is that the server and client are tightly coupled, so that the same entity must own both.
So here’s a potential litmus test: what makes media open is whether any potential pair of clients and servers can work together to fetch it and render it.”