I (gringo) had a conversation last night with a friend (paisa). My friend likened the volunteer vigilantes who patrol the US-Mex border to the colombian paramilitary. I freely admit that i don´t know much about either of these two groups, but at first glance it seemed to me an unfair comparrison.
It reminded me of a comparison sometimes made between the German concentracion camps and the Japanese internment camps, which were not the same thing.
Any comments from someone better-informed on this topic?
By wabbits on Jul 11, 2008, 11:57 in Politics & the war.
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:11: While the minutemen are a bunch of armed, racist thugs and have the tacit approval of the government, they have yet to rise to the level of murdering thousands and driving hundreds of thousands from their homes. For the moment, the comparison is not quite valid.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
aztec says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:17: wabbits, I lived next door to a soldier who survived the Bataan March and was held in one of those Japanese internment camps. They were unbelievably brutal. You do know the Japanese never signed the Geneva Convention protocols regarding POW's?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Catfish35 says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:31: CGringo, here here..I totally agree. Most people are not familiar with the Zetas or their origins however that would be interesting to watch the fat beer bellied racist wanna be vigilantes called Minutemen face off with them just once. "So many guns, and so few brains". sam spade 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:38: I did not know CNN and BBC were Mexican TV. The things one learns on these fora.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
aztec says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:46: kernow62, welcome back. Of course the are not the same. Didn't mean to imply they were. When I am in Bogota about all you see on local TV is CNN, BBC and the news from Mexico.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 11, 2008, 12:55: aztec,
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
deathnova says on Jul 11, 2008, 13:21: I have no problem with them so long as the Border Patrol keeps them in check and any actions they take are purely in self defense.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 11, 2008, 15:44: fill me in, i thought the "minute men" was a group in north dakota...ala ruby ridge. wrong? dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Lcacique says on Jul 11, 2008, 16:06: Here you go, douglas... Hoy se nota en la floresta un ambiente de alegría. ¡Y el rumor de ranchería es mas dulce y sabe a fiesta! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 11, 2008, 16:24: DMW...you are thinking about the Michigan Militia. All in all militias tend to be like para military groups in Colombia...in my opinion. There might have been some good in the beginnings but they all tend to devolve into the same type of hate groups. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
pilotguy says on Jul 11, 2008, 16:29: Try to cross my property on the Mexico/U.S. Border and I will defend my self. And uphold the law. Period. joe
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 11, 2008, 16:38: Hmmm pilotguy you live in Manizales and yet you have a border on Mexico and the U.S. interesting. At any rate you surely have the right to defend yourself. Joe Horn and his shooting of the two Colombians proves that. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 11, 2008, 17:19: pilotguy,
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 11, 2008, 20:09: CG...I agree. Deport the illegals; but, deport at least one citizen along with them that aided and abeted their activities. From someone using illegal housekeepers to corporate bosses turning a blind eye in order to save a dollar. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
pilotguy says on Jul 12, 2008, 05:27: Lpdiver, not sure what you find unusual about owning property in more than one country, interesting.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 12, 2008, 07:42: sheer curiosity....you just shoot someone 'cause they cross your property? hmmmmm. dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
sloopskipper says on Jul 12, 2008, 08:19: pilotguy says on Jul 11, 2008, 16:29: flag
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
sanandressi says on Jul 12, 2008, 08:26: The MINUTEMEN are NOT armed thugs Colombian Gringo they are US CITIZENS simply trying to call attention to the FACT that the United States Government is doing little and has done little to stop the flow of ILLEGAL immigrants and lots of DRUGS which originate in COLOMBIA, BOLIVIA and PERU, from coming across the southern border! Support Plan Colombia, re-elect ilena Ros-Lehtinen 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 12, 2008, 08:39: i would take issue with your statememt the the u.s. govt. has done "little" to inforce the border. they've done one hell of a lot more than any group of malitia men. dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
viajero123 says on Jul 12, 2008, 08:57: What are the minutemen? Do they have the right to shoot someone just trespassing and crossing the border, or do they have to have their lives threatened to do it?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
tasco66 says on Jul 12, 2008, 08:58: "i would take issue with your statememt the the u.s. govt. has done "little" to inforce the border. they've done one hell of a lot more than any group of malitia men." Bravo, Presidente Uribe for the perfect operation! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
greg says on Jul 12, 2008, 09:56: The minutemen tried to get something going on the border up here in NY but i think they realized what they were up against and gave up
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 12, 2008, 10:31: i liked that tasco. cool. well at least the homies can run back across and try again manana. si o no? mil ves mejor de carcel. dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Lcacique says on Jul 12, 2008, 10:57: If the mexicans were not crossing the border, it'd be a pretty boring life for the border patrol. Hoy se nota en la floresta un ambiente de alegría. ¡Y el rumor de ranchería es mas dulce y sabe a fiesta! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
kernow62 says on Jul 12, 2008, 12:23: Where are they going to deport the Americans who hire illegals to? Who would want them? You can't deport them to Mexico because then Mexico would deport them to the US. I say let all the Mexicans who want to come in. Then I will move to Mexico.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
pilotguy says on Jul 12, 2008, 15:42: Trespassing on a persons property IS against the law. period. Uphold the law. Bleeding hearts can yell all they want.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
sloopskipper says on Jul 12, 2008, 16:40: Only the governement can uphold the law, not half-wit locals. You want to shoot Latinos (or anybody who steps on your grass)? But live in Latin America? What's wrong with this picture?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
sloopskipper says on Jul 12, 2008, 16:42: You had better jump on a plane, I heard there is a Mexican pissin' on your petunias!
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
sloopskipper says on Jul 12, 2008, 17:14: Perhaps you could get one of your big helicopters and shoot everyone within 25 miles of the border. That'd be real macho and patriotic.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
pilotguy says on Jul 12, 2008, 17:39: No, being a liberal, whining bleeding heart would be better. I do not live in Safe Panama, I am a permanent resident here, married to a colombiana. You are worried about mexicans, go back and help them. Talking only about it means nothing. Who is impressed with your lack of knowledge.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
aztec says on Jul 12, 2008, 18:08: I saw a billboard yesterday that read:
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 12, 2008, 21:26: sanandressi, They are a joke and will accomplish nothing. The only thing they will accomplish is getting themselves or someone else killed. I wouldn't piss on a Minuteman if he was on fire. Also, when it comes to being prejudiced hypocrites, nobody beats Hispanics in the US. They will rail against the "wetbacks" when their own parents or grandparents waded across illegally. It doesn't surprise me that some Hispanics are part of that ridiculous organization.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 13, 2008, 05:53: nice post, CG....how many of each and every one of our elders--sometime back--came over the borders from somewhere? we came from all over the world. we're us. get used to it. dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
george jung says on Jul 13, 2008, 07:24: Pilotguy, don't pay attention to old no life sloop, he just babbles on about things just to hear himself,his ideas are way way old school back in prehistoric days. I am with you on some of your views. "Men and fish are alot alike, when they open their mouths, they both get in trouble" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 13, 2008, 09:07: The only thing that will accomplish is that more of these big companies will move over the border with their workers. Our own policies have had a big part in the increased number of illegals. Years ago, Mexicans regularly traveled to work in the US, often doing seasonal agricultural work and then would return home for a few months usually around Christmas. These were mostly younger men. The women and children usually remained in Mexico or wherever with their extended family. Well we tightened up border security and this made the free flow of labour very difficult. The risk to these men was too great, so instead they took the risk of bring their wives and children. So now instead of a largely male population we have the women and children too. The effect has been to increase the numbers here instead of its desired effect. This puts more strain on schools and health care.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Robert Jorge says on Jul 13, 2008, 11:27: I have a bumper sticker that says: "I found Jesus" .... "he snuck into my trunk in Jaurez" BEWARE of gold diggers. 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 13, 2008, 12:04: dwmte7,
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Robert Jorge says on Jul 13, 2008, 12:06: Just go by a truck stop Douglas. They probably have those stickers there. BEWARE of gold diggers. 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 13, 2008, 15:37: CG- it is a complicated issue. What about all the Colombians that come to visit "Disneyland" and never leave? Then they proceed to start a "Publito Paisa" restaurant and make thousands and thousands of dollars. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
mranderson says on Jul 13, 2008, 17:04: illegals crossing the border can be dangerous. I have a friend who lives very close to the border and she keeps 5 dogs outside her property all day and night in case an illegal comes on her property. Many of them break into houses looking for food or whatever and a desperate illegal is always bad especially when you are sleeping.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 13, 2008, 18:52: A lot of illegals also pay taxes and reap no benefits. In Orlando, illegals are told before they can be employed they must obtain an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number. The employer actually takes taxes from these workers and the IRS gladly will accept it. The IRS will not cause problems until they don't pay the taxes, then watch out. You can buy these ITINs at most local Latino businesses.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Lcacique says on Jul 14, 2008, 00:41: I remember in 1997, the first time that the military was deployed to the Mexican border since 1910. What happens? They shoot a young American student. Essentially they got away with murder. There is a great documentary on the subject called the Ballad of Esequiel Hernández. FBI agents and Marine investigators all claim that the trial was absolutely bogus and that all of the evidence points to a murder being committed. First time the military had killed an innocent civilian on US soil since Kent State. Hoy se nota en la floresta un ambiente de alegría. ¡Y el rumor de ranchería es mas dulce y sabe a fiesta! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
viajero123 says on Jul 14, 2008, 01:05: mranderson "I don't have any problems with the minute men. They are doing something that the government has failed to do. Or they are trying anyway. Better to make an effort rather then sit back and do nothing." sounds to me like the same thing that paramilitaries say.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 14, 2008, 02:40: The minute men are paramilitaries. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jul 14, 2008, 04:19: heh, lp...what happened to the rice cookoff? dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Iowano says on Jul 14, 2008, 11:22: I live in a small city in a safe part of the U.S. A couple of years ago I wrote a letter to the editor defending Mexican immigrants. The next day I got a threatening phone call from a local militia member. An eye-opening experience.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 14, 2008, 13:34: I hope you reminded him that you have the right to free speech.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Tinto (Moderator) says on Jul 14, 2008, 13:40: I thought the MinuteMen were a bunch of angry/bored/retired guys sitting in lawn chairs on government property, armed with nothing more than cell phones and binoculars? Have they ever been charged with a crime?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Lcacique says on Jul 14, 2008, 15:32: I do not think they have been involved in any criminal activity and I have not heard any complaints about their activity from border patrol. Hoy se nota en la floresta un ambiente de alegría. ¡Y el rumor de ranchería es mas dulce y sabe a fiesta! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 14, 2008, 18:36: I saw a documentary where they interviewed some border patrol who didn't want them around. I think it was on Link TV. I suppose they might get in the way. The same show talked about one of the guys (I can't recall his name) but the FBI had been watching him for years. He has a huge stockpile of weapons and fancies himself a soldier of fortune.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Robert Jorge says on Jul 14, 2008, 21:37: The programs and articles that I have read concerning the minutemen, say and show they are unarmed, and watch out over private property. In other words, they are literally on one of their own farms watching for illegals. If they see border skippers, they simply call the Border Patrol. BEWARE of gold diggers. 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 15, 2008, 08:24: The show I saw showed them with full face paint, AR15s, night vision, body armour, dressed all in black.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 15, 2008, 08:28: You can get some idea of the sort who see themselves as Minutemen by reading some of this forum.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 15, 2008, 09:06: Kernow, I don't think that those are the same minutemen. It looks like you've found a militia forum. I must admit that there is some pretty disturbing shit on that site.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jul 15, 2008, 09:16: all migration should be legal... yes I believe in the borderless world.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kalder says on Jul 15, 2008, 09:27: Would you do away with money as well? "kalder- have you ever had a woman?"--Sam Salmon 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jul 15, 2008, 11:38: if I felt like it would make a difference and there was greater commitment from society.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 15, 2008, 12:30: ColombianoGringo Why do you say those militia guys are not the minutemen?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ColombianoGringo says on Jul 15, 2008, 12:51: The minutemen we were talking about are not really a militia. Roberto's description is fairly accurate, but some of them are supposedly armed.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 16, 2008, 09:50: The Minuteman Pledge "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Tinto (Moderator) says on Jul 16, 2008, 10:01: Whatever you think of the issue, here's a funny headline you won't see in the NY Times.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
Cerealkiller says on Jul 16, 2008, 10:11: I saw a documentary on skinheads and white pride freaks moving down south and joining the minutemen... Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives -John Stuart Mill 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
lpdiver says on Jul 16, 2008, 10:40: dwmte7..."heh, lp...what happened to the rice cookoff?" Google up Poo Poo Broussard and look for his Alien Dat video...that is where my "cook some rice" by line originates. It is some funny stuff. He is a co workers neighbor. "cook some rice!" 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
kernow62 says on Jul 16, 2008, 13:48: So it is all God's fault. He gave all these rights, What did he pop down and make the US his land or something? It is as silly as the Royals in England believing they are ordained by God.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
More posts by the same author:
currency rates with historical chart? 6
dental cleaning.. contact lenses... etc. better done in Colombia or the US? 19
design studios / ad agencies / posthouses in Medellin ? 1
TEFL training on the job, or thru a certified course? 10
Americas: |
Africa: |
Asia:
|
Travel: Also: |
If you're not a part of this travelicious experiment just yet, just sign up here. It's free & easy.
About poorbuthappy | About the travel guides | Travel guide editing | Community rules | RSS feeds
© 1998 - 2008 Peter Van Dijck, all rights reserved.