Thought-provoking article I found at http://dc.indymedia.org/newswire/display/143340/index.php
I have just finished reading INTERPOL's report on the computers that the government of Colombia says it found in an encampment of the FARC-EP on March 1. Reading the report I am once again fascinated with what experts can do with computers. But I am shocked that the world's best known detective agency cannot add three plus three.
INTERPOL in Colombia 3 + 3 = 8
by Charlie Hardy - May 20, 2008
I have just finished reading INTERPOL's report on the computers that the government of Colombia says it found in an encampment of the FARC-EP on March 1. Reading the report I am once again fascinated with what experts can do with computers. But I am shocked that the world's best known detective agency cannot add three plus three.
On pages 10 and 11 of the report in English, Interpol begins a description about how it came to be involved in the work. It says that on March 4 it received a request from Colombian authorities asking for Interpol's "independent computer forensic technical assistance to examine the user files on the eight seized FARC computer exhibits".
In Appendix 2, they show a letter that they received from Brigadier General Oscar Adolor Narnjo Truillo, Director General of the National Police of Colombia. In the letter General Naranjo requests that INTERPOL evaluate "three (3) computers and three (3) USB devices." Adding three and three, I arrive at a total of six pieces of computer hardware not eight as INTERPOL mentioned.
The next day Mr. Ronald K. Nobel, the Secretary General of Interpol, sent a letter (Appendix 3) to Ms. Maria del Pilar Hurtado Afanador, the directress of the D.A.S (Departamento Administrativo de Seguridad) in Bogota accepting the invitation to go to Colombia to establish the terms of the agreement. In the letter he, again, mentions six pieces of hardware: "three (3) computers and three (3) USB keys."
But on March 6 Ms. Hurtado sends him a letter (Appendix 4) asking that Interpol look at "the three lap-top computers, the three USB keys and two hard-disk drives." On March 4 there were only six items to look at, but for some reason two hard drives were found someplace by March 6.
Throughout their report, INTERPOL speaks of eight pieces of hardware, but I find no place where it questions why the government originally asked them to check only six pieces. It would seem to me that any reputable detective group would ask for such an explanation.
For multiple reasons, the INTERPOL report doesn't fit my description of good detective work that I learned from Dick Tracy, Columbo and G.K. Chesterton's Father Brown.
Throughout the report INTERPOL speaks of the hardware as belonging to Raul Reyes, although they never present any proof of this. This in itself shows prejudice on the part of INTERPOL. The two experts that reviewed the hardware do not speak Spanish. Who were the experts that decided the computers and materials belonged to Reyes? There is a photo in the report showing Reyes sitting in front of a computer. That's proof that the computers and hardware belonged to him? Dick Tracy would have looked for fingerprints, not only of Raul Reyes (which actually could have been put on the computers after he was dead) but of the authorities who touched the computers also. Father Brown would have wondered how the Colombian authorities could find so rapidly documents that said the FARC-EP helped finance Chávez's political campaign in the '90s and that, as president, Chávez had offered them three hundred million dollars. And I think Columbo would have had more than one question to ask Ms. Hurtado before he walked out the door of the D.A.S. office.
By the way, speaking of Colombian authorities, the report says: "Colombian law enforcement authorities have openly stated to INTERPOL's computer forensic experts that an officer in their anti-terrorist unit directly accessed the eight seized FARC computer exhibits under exigent and time-sensitive circumstances between 1 March 2008, when they were seized by Colombian authorities, and 3 March 2008." In my opinion that sentence was included to show how the Colombian government cooperated with INTERPOL in the task it was given. But I cannot believe that simply "an officer" did everything with the computers during those first three days. To me it is another indication of the the way Colombia has distorted what has happened in the events surrounding those days of the attack on Ecuadorian territory.
And referring to Ecuador, President Rafael Correa has said that if we are to believe what the FARC-EP has supposedly said about Ecuador than we should also believe what they have to say about President Uribe's links to drug trafficking and to the para-militaries. Now that INTERPOL has made back-up copies of everything on these eight pieces of hardware, it would be nice if Colombia would share them with Venezuela and Ecuador so that these countries, which seem to be mentioned so frequently in the computers, could see if any mention is made about Colombia in them.
But in any case, it would seem to me that anyone with common sense would put little credibility into whatever comes out of these supposed pieces of evidence. Where did the computers come from? Who did they belong to? Who put the information into them? Even if they were used by Raul Reyes and even if he did enter some items into them, is it possible that an infiltrated person also put items into the computers? There are a multitude of who, what, when, where, why, and how questions that are not answered in the report. More seriously, they are not even asked.
But if you are looking for someone to answer the questions, I wouldn't call on INTERPOL. Where are Dick Tracy, Father Brown and Colombo now that we need them?
Finally, I would suggest reading the the report itself, an article that appeared on Venezuelanalysis.com and a commentary by Eva Golinger.
-30- (Charles Hardy is author of Cowboy in Caracas: A North American's Memoir of Venezuela's Democratic Revolution, published by Curbstone Press. Other essays by Hardy can be found on his personal blog Cowboyincaracas.com . You may write him at cowboyincaracas (at) yahoo.com . )
narcosphere.narconews.com/notebook/charlie-hardy...
snipurl.com/29wqb
www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php
See also:
colombia.indymedia.org/news/2008/05/87320_comment.php
and:
-- “The War Machine: Or How to Manipulate Reality�
By Eva Golinger:
www.chavezcode.com/2008/05/war-machine-or-how-to-manipulate.html
-- “Extradition of Paramilitary Leaders Undermines Para-Politics Investigation�
by Garry Leech :
www.colombiajournal.org/colombia282.htm
By ixent on Jun 20, 2008, 12:22 in Politics & the war.
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 12:23: I have verified some of the things in the article above to be true, by scanning the report, but haven't had time to read it all. It is located at:
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 12:30: I would also question the efficacy of checking a timestamp on a computer file. If you type "change file timestamp" into google there is a plethora of software which will assist you with this. For example:
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 20, 2008, 12:32: great work ixent. this is unbelivable what you have discovered... I have a basic rule that if Uribe or his lackies say it I hardly believe it. But I did not know about the specifics of this report like you have provided. 'The war machinery' is truly something that has taken over our lives...
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
truthspeaker says on Jun 20, 2008, 12:44: Could it be that a PC could have had more than an hard drive or that they were externally attached to the computers? Remember, I can only tell the truth. No more Sex Tourism in Colombia. 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
billyb says on Jun 20, 2008, 12:46: Math lesson fellers, there were 2 external drives.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:02: The most worrying point, to me, is the fact that the interpol investigation did not involve actually verifying the origin of the hardware they examined. Throughout the report they just basically take for-granted that it is the case that the hardware was seized from the farc.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
billyb says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:04: "Colombian commandos recovered the three Toshiba Satellite laptop computers, two external hard drives and three USB memory sticks in a March 1 cross-border raid into Ecuador that killed FARC foreign minister Raul Reyes and 24 others."
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
gato-bandido says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:04: > Or do you think that Interpol detectives are a bunch of dumb guys?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:07: are you quoting USAtoday when you need to be quoting the interpol report???
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:10: Errrm... the usatoday article is based on an interpretation of the Interpol report. So please, if you are going to counter-argue, use the original source, ie. the interpol report. I know it's over 100 pages long, but it's the most reliable source.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
billyb says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:22: The fact remains that there were 2 external drives, sorry boys, you'll have to postpone your frothing for another occassion.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:39: how about you read the interpol report and actually make an argument... the key issue isn't the 3 3.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
billyb says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:41: "the key issue isn't the 3 3."
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:51: the title "INTERPOL in Colombia 3 3 = 8" simply alludes to the fact that the interpol report does not add up, which is the subject of this thread.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 20, 2008, 13:56: discussing with billyb is like talking to a rock... why do I bother?
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
|
romy says on Jun 20, 2008, 14:25: I think it's because you seem to have a brain... however you let your feelings distort your rationality, which is a truly intriguing mix.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
billyb says on Jun 20, 2008, 14:29: "at least your cheerleader complex seems to be somehwhat resolved, that was also entertaining"
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:08: before this post descends into personal attacks, I'd like to urge people to address the intial issues which were raised, making reference to the interpol report.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
jorgegdiaz says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:32: Ixent, I know you are a computer expert, and I know it`s easy to find timestamps in a Windows based machine. Easy to manipulate... I wouldn`t know how. "To err is human - and to blame it on a computer is even more so."Robert Orben 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:41: jorgegdiaz, I am not refusing an interpol report.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
robi666 says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:45: If someone could find some articles from newspaper about the death of RR and computers finding, I think it would be easy to realize if the existence of the external disks was known at the time (I mean, before the Interpol was requested to investigate). "I am a citizen of the most beautiful nation on earth. A nation whose laws are harsh yet simple, a nation that never cheats, which is immense and without borders, where life is lived in the present." 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
robi666 says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:48: More, what could be the reason to add two more disks to the computers? "I am a citizen of the most beautiful nation on earth. A nation whose laws are harsh yet simple, a nation that never cheats, which is immense and without borders, where life is lived in the present." 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:49: Jorgegdiaz, to answer your other question, I did not refer to a usa today report, I was reponding to billyb about an usa today report which he had cited (see post above).
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
jorgegdiaz says on Jun 20, 2008, 15:50: I read most of the report when it came out. Yes, they saved their butts by stating how the specimens were obtained. "To err is human - and to blame it on a computer is even more so."Robert Orben 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
tasco66 says on Jun 21, 2008, 04:44: You mean to say Chavez turned his coat based on some spotty Interpol report? Bravo, Presidente Uribe for the perfect operation! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
tasco66 says on Jun 21, 2008, 04:54: From Wikipedia: Bravo, Presidente Uribe for the perfect operation! 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
dwmte7 says on Jun 21, 2008, 06:19: they just need a lesson from our homies...."...one and one and one is three..." dwmte 0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 21, 2008, 06:56: Tasco66, I'm perfectly happy to acknowledge that all news entities report from their political perspective, and that this is the nature of all media. This is the case whether it's left wing/right wing/mainstream/whatever. Therefore I maintain my point of view that scepticism of **all** media is a healthy thing to have, whatever your political affiliation is.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
ixent says on Jun 21, 2008, 06:57: Tasco66, the Interpol report is at http://www.interpol.int/Public/ICPO/PressReleases/PR2008/pdfPR200817/i.... Read the paragraph in page 7 about the scope of the report. It's only one paragraph.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
juancegomez says on Jun 26, 2008, 09:50: I read this article elsewhere, and I am still profoundly unimpressed. And yes, that is after reading the INTERPOL report for myself, in a less selective way than the above author if I am allowed to say so.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
juancegomez says on Jun 26, 2008, 10:25: A couple of interesting quotes from the article:
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 26, 2008, 10:29: "How they describe their foes is one thing, what
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
juancegomez says on Jun 26, 2008, 10:46: Again, I have to assume that FARC would describe their own operations in a different manner than when they state "Uribe is a paramilitary".
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 26, 2008, 11:04: of course it's wrong because it's pretentious. but it's a 'catch 22' because assumptions must be made otherwise. We really have to wait and see, like you have pointed out elsewhere.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
juancegomez says on Jun 26, 2008, 11:32: Actually, if you look at the condition of the body, it seems somewhat likely that Raúl Reyes stepped on a land mine while he was fleeing.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 26, 2008, 11:37: I haven't seen the condition of his body... that's why I asked.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
juancegomez says on Jun 26, 2008, 11:53: Here's a link I found through Google image search, but I warn you...it's pretty graphic and, I would add, horrible.
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
|
romy says on Jun 26, 2008, 12:27: I see the need for the services of someone like http://explosion-experts.com/
0 funny, 0 helpful. |
More posts by the same author:
Train from Puerto Berrio to Barrancabermeja 8
Urgentemente necesito buen psicologo para adolescentes 0
Urgently need GOOD teenage psychologist - Bogota or Ibague 2
Whatever happened to Platano? 116
School for "problem children" in Colombia 37
Brief travel guide to Mompox 6
Poorbuthappy guide for Ibagué 7
Plantation house hostel, Salento 2
Mompox 8
Flying from UK to Bogota with DELTA 21
Change in US policy regarding illegal Immigration 83
Implications for Colombia if the US attacked Venezuela? 23
Does this site need an FAQ/guidelines? 3
Americas: |
Africa: |
Asia:
|
Travel: Also: |
If you're not a part of this travelicious experiment just yet, just sign up here. It's free & easy.
About poorbuthappy | About the travel guides | Travel guide editing | Community rules | RSS feeds
© 1998 - 2008 Peter Van Dijck, all rights reserved.