| pbh home > > post |
Join in 7 seconds.. Existing users: sign in.
![]() |
all forums, active | friendly talkzone, travel tips, visa & paperwork, renting, selling & meetups, politics & the war, espanol
Reading these other threads about gringos sending money to their fianceés in Colombia I was just wondering about if you all knew that people seldom get engaged in Colombia. It's not very common to change rings and celebrate an enagagement before getting married. A Colombian woman might consider an engagement ring with a huge diamond or whatever a nice present from the gringo boyfriend, not a sign of true commitment.
Anyway, that's what I believe the custom is in Colombia. If it has changed since I lived in Colombia feel free to correct me.
Cheers,
Desi
By Desideria (Moderator) on Sep 7, 2005, 13:00 in Friendly Talkzone.
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 13:15: I got my girlfriend something simple. The jeweler who is making her ring doesn't offer insurance outside the United States, so I got her something simple. She kept showing it to her girlfriends and relatives. She told me it would "look bad" for her to move into my apartment in El Laguito without some kind of public declaration that we were comprometidos. For example, I can't spend the night in the same bed with her at her parents house because we're not married. But then, I didn't want to spend the night alone in my apt. So... to legitimize it a little bit for publicity's sake, I gave her the little ring. In front of everybody. On one knee. With a band playing. And her parents applauding. At no time did it seem like the concept of being engaged was foreign to them.
|
|
Crazy4Cali says on Sep 7, 2005, 13:55: I dunno.... ...it seemed like a big deal to my novia, her family, and her compañeros de trabajo when we were officially engaged.
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 14:23: I'm with Desi on this one I don't think there are any hard and fast rule on this one, but in general, I think a gringo or any other guy who makes a habit of shipping of $$ to some Colombiana, has got to get his head examined.
|
|
Crazy4Cali says on Sep 7, 2005, 14:28: Agreed.. I should probably have my head examined, but I think that's besides the point. But I'm not one of those gringos blindly sending dollars or other things to Colombia...esp. now that my Colombianita is here in the U.S.
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 14:29: By the time you buy the engagement ring, you already HAVE the girl, Gomez. That last comment doesn't even belong on this thread. Next you'll be saying I should only call her collect, refusing to spend any money on the phone bill. And this from a guy who admittedly has no problem paying for sex. Buying an engagement ring is utterly ridiculous, but you going out and paying for ass is defensible? What are you smoking?
|
|
caslug says on Sep 7, 2005, 14:35: A BIG question would be.. DO COL GUYS BUY ENGAGEMENT RING or just wedding ring? If the local guys don't do it then foreign guys dont have to either.
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 14:44: Cam0940 Have you lost your marbles sir? Look, if you're going to debate, then do it honestly and don't put words in my hand. Fair enough?
|
|
BAQ says on Sep 7, 2005, 15:04: My wife Can't speak with any intelligence about the "Custom" but a few years back when I asked my wife to marry me (here in Colombia), as soon as she watched me pull the ring out, she KNEW what it was (engagement ring) and what it meant. I couldn;t even get the words out of my mouth "Will you marry me" before she got all excited and said yes. Semper Fidelis ! |
|
tomtom33 says on Sep 7, 2005, 15:10: If you love her, don't buy her a huge diamond ring. You will make her a target.
|
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 15:43: OK, Gomez You never said you patronized prostitutes, and I apologize for saying otherwise. You did defend the practice vehemently. Your personal action/inaction is actually beside the point. Your belief was that if the woman wanted to sell, it was her body. By extension then, it is OK for the man to pay.
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 16:09: Cam0940 With all due respect, I am not going to debate the issue as to the morality or imorrality of prostitution. That issue has already been debated in another thread, and we will have to just agree to disagree. Neither you or I have anything new to bring to the table.
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 16:35: I did apologize for an irresponsible comment, and clarified myself. Your personal action/inaction is irrelevant in this ideological discussion. You needn't patronize prostitutes nor I have a Colombian fiancee for us to debate this issue.
|
|
rona says on Sep 7, 2005, 17:00: looks like times are changing then . . . My fiancee and I got engaged last year and we had a nice dinner with both our parents and close relatives to formalize it . . . everything seemed perfectly normal, nothing seemed out of the ordinary for them . . . if you look in "El Universal" in the "Sociales" section you'll see every now and then people announcing their engagements the same way you would announce your wedding . . .
|
|
kat1 (Moderator) says on Sep 7, 2005, 17:18: I just want to say this, Am I I bought our wedding rings, they are engrave each other with our names, My husband bought me the engagement ring earlier. engage brain before opening mouth |
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 17:43: Apology Accepted Thanks...and now to your Q. The two actions you are comparing are very unrelated in my opinion because while on the surface they seem related, in actuality, they are not.
|
|
Rubiazo says on Sep 7, 2005, 17:49: According to my gf giving a girl a ring before you are married is perfectly normal here and a way of showing you are serious!
|
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 17:59: Well I'd have to say.. I got engaged in the church atop Monserrate. Screw the superstition. That's all it is.
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 18:14: G5 For someone who is so opposed to relationships and swears them off, I don't think you should be dishing out advice to those who wish to pursue one. Maybe you're one of these Latino's who doesn't like the thought of Gringo's and Latina's together and so, you offer your distortion of these intercontinental relationships, when you yourself are not even in a serious relationship. Really, you're out of touch with the situation and should probably not get too involved in long-distance relationship discussions, let alone local, because so far you've clearly indicated nothing more than the fact that your viewpoints as you've stated them are clear distortions loosely based on your own bad experiences.
|
|
BAQ says on Sep 7, 2005, 18:23: Humm Girlfriend, Fiance, Wife = Sex with Commitment Semper Fidelis ! |
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 19:35: Mario....I don't have a clue of what your are talking about Your post made absolutely no sense in that it was not applicable in to me.
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 19:50: Well Gomez No one who has no more in common than a fish and a bird should be together, whether they live next door to each other or in separate hemispheres. I'll give you that.
|
|
rona says on Sep 7, 2005, 19:59: every discussion needs a G5 . . . . . . I think you guys are taking G5's comments WAY TOO PERSONALLY - I met a Colombiana, got engaged, brought her here and we're about to get married - we couldn't be happier . . . Whereas G5 brings up valid points, I don't believe they apply to me - for those of you that get bent out of shape from a different point of view, maybe you need to re-examine your relationships because he obviously touched a nerve . .
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:05: Literary skills to the extent that I posess them Well, first the expression is actually thus: "putting words in my mouth". The other expression is "talk to the hand" which is by and large what you should do. It seems that you use your adaptation of the first expression often around here so I suppose many of us must really be mistakenly putting words in your hand. LOL...
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:11: cam......lol....I like that post.....most ammusing!! Bonds??? Look, the only bonds I know about is the one that a person has to post to get out of the pokey. As to attorneys....women attorneys in particular, I'll be my ussual reserved self, We work on a professional level as needed, have a drink or two but uh beyond that......we part company.
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:15: Rona Congratulations on your happiness in your relationship. The reason some of G5's comments were taken personally was because to an extent they WERE personal, as we have covered some of this in other threads in the past. He even mentioned my name in his analysis today, except that he doesn't know me, my girlfriend, or the nature of our relationship. That's what makes it offensive.
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:22: LOL "I could have been like Mario and others who give you the "listen to your heart" nonsense. On the other hand, I would rather you listen to your heart, than listening to other parts of your anatomy--like may men do."
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:26: Yeah, he's always doing that, and then in the next breath tries to rise above it.
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:37: Mario....this will be short (believe it or not) Past relationship with Colombiana (had). She decided to stay to run the family business when Father and mother took ill. We talk every other day. Her house is mine and the reverse is true.
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:42: Shit....I'm out of Wisers Now what am I going to do. Damn it. I don't even have any more CR special reserve. This will have been my first whiskey in almost a week!! and now,,,nothing!!
|
|
BAQ says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:44: Oh my Holy God Oh my holy god, we have gone from Engaged to Prostitution to ATTORNEYS !!!!!!!! Semper Fidelis ! |
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 7, 2005, 20:56: Listen BAQ That's what I love about this board too!! Whenever, I say say: "Checkmate", (It's a few extra words to get there)they all go for one of the two jugulars. (Attorney....or my spelling) That is when I know I have once again come out on top.
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 21:18: Kernow's Syndrome? Sounds like a personal attack - which I hope he can "take well to".
|
|
Mario says on Sep 7, 2005, 21:19: Prostitution, Attorney's... what's the difference?
|
|
morphus says on Sep 7, 2005, 21:31: i plan to get married when women start accepting cubic zirconia rings. technically, its a real diamond, just man made. they only cost around $200 and look great :)
|
|
utopiacowboy says on Sep 7, 2005, 21:57: Kat, we did almost the same as you. We have gold wedding bands which my wife bought with each other's name engraved inside. I bought her a little engagement ring earlier. Disclaimer: any comment I make is inane and is not to be taken seriously, and is so patently ridiculous that no one should take it seriously, even as an insult. |
|
nanis says on Sep 8, 2005, 03:07: I don't think getting engaged is very common in Colombia, we don't have as much money to spend for an engagement party and an engagement ring and all that nonsense you have to go through but don't get me wrong i believe that getting engaged is a very romantic tradition just no practical enough for us colombians i guess well not at least for the poor ones like myself and to be honest i never met anyone in colombia who went through the whole engagement process before.
|
|
kernow62 says on Sep 8, 2005, 03:30: Now we're talking morphus, that is my kind of girl. I have a confession, I did do that, well the engagement ring was a CZ. The wedding ring was real and I replaced the engagement ring later when I could afford it, even though my wife said it wasn't important to her. My fiance was only too happy to accept the CZ as she said it was only symbolic. I knew right there and then this girl was a keeper.
|
|
|
kat1 (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 05:10: My husband ask my dad for my My husband asked my dad for my hand in marriage, he then got me my engagement ring, and bought the weddings because I had a jeweller friend and he gave a very good prices for the rings, two for the price of one jejeje. I had a "party La despedida de soltera" Organised by my sister, and they gave me nice pressies :-).My parents paid for the whole wedding things. engage brain before opening mouth |
|
quindioman says on Sep 8, 2005, 06:06: damn I finally sussed out how to screw up a good relationship......get engaged...yep. Been engaged twice and I don't think I'm any nearer to the altar...in fact my first serious relationship with a calena in London lasted 5 years....brilliant. I proposed, we got engaged and were finished 7 months later.
|
|
cam0940 says on Sep 8, 2005, 08:30: G5 Love you like a brother Gomez, but Mario's got a point. If you handle divorces, seems it might affect your objectivity towards relationships. Can you comment on that?
|
|
Gomezman5 says on Sep 8, 2005, 09:50: Cam buddy...trust me I don't take my work home. Family law is still a relatively small part of my practice. If the amount of divorces affected me, than those who limited their practice exclusively to Family law, would all be nuts. As a pro., I am able to seperate work from my own day to day life experiences. In other words, my mind is not jaded.
|
|
Desideria (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 09:52: Mrs. Gómez, that's exactly how I got married too, in Colombia. No formal engagement just set a date for the wedding and bought the rings with the names and dates engraved inside. As a matter of fact, I don't know anybody who was engaged in Colombia. I've seen an occasional engagement announcement in the newspapers (sociales), but they were always associated with ultra religious, ultra conservative type Opus Dei people. Regular folks just got married. "I have opinions of my own, strong opinions, but I don't always agree with them."-President George W. Bush |
|
Mr. Hollywood says on Sep 8, 2005, 10:16: Curious? I'm unclear about this. If there's no "engagement" in Colombia, how does it work that someone asks another person to marry, they agree, and then they plan a wedding? That's all engagement means to me: I asked, she accepted, we're getting married. It also has been a universal pattern everywhere I live.
|
|
Desideria (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 10:24: Hollywood, I'm not overly familiar with the custom in the States and have myself never been engaged, but I had an idea that an engagement is a bit more formal than that. Engagement rings are exchanged (I guess in the States only the fianceé gets a ring), both families are notified and there's usually a small party to celebrate the engagement. In Colombia there may be a priest present to bless the engagement. Here in Scandinavia when people get engaged (very few do at this time and age) there's a small announcement in the local newspaper too. An engagement can be cancelled by just returning the rings. "I have opinions of my own, strong opinions, but I don't always agree with them."-President George W. Bush |
|
cam0940 says on Sep 8, 2005, 10:45: Well Desi then that explains the confusion. In the States, engaged just means you are promised to be married. It starts from the moment the boyfriend asks the girlfriend if she'll marry him (though technically it could be vice versa, with her asking him). Typically, the ring is a symbol that you've moved beyond the casual relationship and you're getting married. No party necessary. No announcement necessary in the newspaper. All of that is optional. And there is no TIME requirement for the engagement. If I proposed to you, and you said "Sure let's go do it in Vegas this weekend", then we'd be "engaged" for today and tomorrow, up until we took our vows. That's all there is to it. It's just making a commitment to go ahead and get married. Typically the engagement ring will be a solitaire diamond. Size and quality, or whether to have a diamond at all, is optional. At the wedding, he gets a band and she gets a second ring, usually less spectacular so as not to detract from the brilliance of her solitaire, to match her engagement ring.
|
|
nanis says on Sep 8, 2005, 10:50: Desi that's what i thought too. to me getting engaged was about telling eachother's families we were going to get married. nothing more (no party, no ring, no nonsense) sometimes a couple can feel too tied down by the whole getting engaged process and they end up spliting up, it's just too much.. if you are going to get married just go ahead and do it that's what i say!
|
|
BAQ says on Sep 8, 2005, 10:57: Back to Engagement Ms. Gomez, ya don;t need to have a party to get engaged. Now being a gringo, I realize the cultures are different, that being said, how hard is it to buy some type of ring, doesn;t have to be much, to give to a woman to show your SERIOUS INTENTION of marriage. It's EASY to say "I love you, I want to marry you", anyone can do that and I suspect there are lots of women who have had men tell them that and never follow through with marriage. Semper Fidelis ! |
|
Desideria (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 11:10: cam, Mrs. Gómez, the rings are optional, the announcement inthe newspaper is also optional, even the party can be optional. Notifying both families about the intent of these two people of getting married and having set the date (also customary) is the very essence of the engament, besides the obvious commitment by the two parties. There are no set rules for this here either; each couple handles this as they best see fit, but it's generally thought as a social commitment as well since the two families will be related by marriage for the foreseeable length of time. "I have opinions of my own, strong opinions, but I don't always agree with them."-President George W. Bush |
|
cam0940 says on Sep 8, 2005, 11:23: OK then we're all on the same page. After your last post, I no longer understand the concerns in the original question. I guess the only difference between the States and CO would be that we typically do give a ring, but the ring is not what makes the engagement. It's just a symbol.
|
|
Desideria (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 11:38: yes, cam but the original concern was about the fact that most Colombians are not even aware of the social implications of a formal engagement. What I described in my previous post is the Scandinavian angle on engagement. When I told my parents that I was getting married the first question was "when did you get engaged? How come we weren't informed?" "I have opinions of my own, strong opinions, but I don't always agree with them."-President George W. Bush |
|
kat1 (Moderator) says on Sep 8, 2005, 14:23: I agree with Mr Hollywood, when my husband gave me the engagement ring that was a sign of commitment to each othe,. Well that was how my parents did it and his parents, so I follow their traditions. engage brain before opening mouth |
|
adrimm says on Sep 8, 2005, 16:22: Bizarre? Hmm I don't know too many platonic friends who kiss and hold hands here. Even friends with benefits tend skip that hand-holding (in public) part.
|
|
tomtom33 says on Sep 8, 2005, 17:00: "... the engagement process is when you sleep together." You have to make sure that they will accept money before you do the deed.
|
|
CaryGrant says on Sep 8, 2005, 18:11: Morphus: "i plan to get married when women start accepting cubic zirconia rings."
|
|
tomtom33 says on Sep 8, 2005, 18:17: CG "...promised pretty much anything to get Colombianas into bed."
|
|
kat1 (Moderator) says on Sep 9, 2005, 04:33: Agree with you adrimm bizarre? engage brain before opening mouth |
|
morphus says on Sep 9, 2005, 07:34: Carygrant, i meant it for the women here in the U.S. i'm sure i can get away with a cubic zirconia in Colombia. i don't think i would ever do the foreign bride thing though. maybe, if i was really ugly or deformed and sitting in a wheelchair.
|
|
CaryGrant says on Sep 9, 2005, 15:44: Morphus I agree with you on foolish Canadian/American women wanting a symbol worth thousands. but your second comment about the foreign bride thing makes me question your experience in life.
|
|
Mario says on Sep 9, 2005, 20:20: In other words... Passing judgement like some idiotic people here is not par for the Libertarian course.
|
|
adrimm says on Sep 9, 2005, 20:47: tomtom3 Gee tomtom
|
|
adrimm says on Sep 9, 2005, 20:50: Also, not all north american women expect a billion dollar rock. I'd say alot are quite sensible and might appreciate a mortgage-approved letter from the bank shown on bended knee with a wedding proposal.
|
|
morphus says on Sep 10, 2005, 07:00: CaryGrant "I agree with you on foolish Canadian/American women wanting a symbol worth thousands. but your second comment about the foreign bride thing makes me question your experience in life"
|
|
utopiacowboy says on Sep 10, 2005, 11:45: So, Morphus, if you were sitting in a wheelchair in your own piss and shit, then you would consider marrying a Colombiana? Disclaimer: any comment I make is inane and is not to be taken seriously, and is so patently ridiculous that no one should take it seriously, even as an insult. |
|
|
morphus says on Sep 10, 2005, 12:03: i'm not marriage minded. i know i could never be monogamous. its just not in my genes. if i was married to the hottest chick, i would still end up cheating at some point. to me, women are like food. i want variety.
|
More posts by the same author:
Switching languages can also switch personality: study 101
Anybody Here With Experience From The Dominican Republic? 6
Increased Legal Protection For Women 40
Come Celebrate Midsummer Ikea Style 17
Not Easy Being A Mum In Colombia 17
Finally! Love In The Time of Cholera here 28
CIAT won the battle over the Bean Thief 10
Putin Following Sarky's Footsteps 4
Sweden May Sell Spy Radar to Colombia 42
Mme Sarcozy uncensored..(adult video) 41
Colombia limita al norte con la tortura 3
557 Reasons 15
Americas: |
Africa: |
Asia:
|
Travel: Also: |
If you're not a part of this travelicious experiment just yet, just sign up here. It's free & easy.
About poorbuthappy | About the travel guides | Travel guide editing | Community rules
© 1998 - 2008 Peter Van Dijck, all rights reserved.